Best Budget Cat Litter (2025)

You don't need to spend $40 a month to avoid smelling cat poop. We found the best cheap litters that actually work.

Tested 15 Products4 Months TestingTested by Humans & Cats

The Winners (Skip the Research)

Overall Winner
Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal
8.7

Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal

Best For

Maximum Odor Blocking

Best Value
Dr. Elsey's Ultra
9.4

Dr. Elsey's Ultra

Best For

Dust-Free Homes

Best Natural
World's Best Cat Litter
9.1

World's Best Cat Litter

Best For

Flushability

3 Products Found
Dr. Elsey's Ultra
9.4

The gold standard. Slightly more expensive than grocery brands, but lasts longer.

Best clumping
No Smell
Heavy bags
Tracking
Boxiecat Premium
9.2

Premium option provided for comparison. Better dust control.

Flat top clumps
Zero dust
Twice the price
Hard to find
Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal
8.7

The best value for odor sealing.

Seals odor instantly
Cheap
Strong perfume
Fine dust

Compare All Products

ProductReview ScorePriceTypeDustClumpingOdorKey Features
8.7
8.7
$$Clay
8/10
9/10
9/10
🌸 Scented
9.4
9.4
$$Clay
9/10
10/10
9/10
⚪ Unscented
9.2
9.2
$$$Clay
10/10
9/10
8.5/10
⚪ Unscented

The Mathematics of Cheap Litter

Cheap litter often costs more in the long run. Why? Because it doesn't form tight clumps. When you scoop, the clump breaks apart, leaving dirty crumbs behind. This forces you to dump the entire box and refill it every week instead of every month.

The "Grocery Store" Trap

Most litters under $10 rely on heavy perfumes to mask odor because they lack the premium ingredients to absorb it.

💡 The Budget "Super-Hack"

Here is how to get $40 performance for $15.

  • Buy the cheapest Unscented clumping clay litter you can find (e.g., Special Kitty).
  • Add one scoop of Purrify Deodorizer ($10).
  • Result: Creates a premium probiotic litter that outperforms the expensive brands.

You save ~50% annually by buying generic litter and boosting it with Purrify.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Tidy Cats worthy buying?

It's okay. The 'Lightweight' version is incredibly dusty (choking hazard). The standard clay version is decent but tracks badly.

How often should I change cheap litter?

Weekly. Unlike premium litter which can last 30 days with scooping, cheap litter saturates with ammonia quickly.